The Guild
Lifespan: 2007 – present | Runtime: 3-8 minutes | Website >>
Starring: Felicia Day, Vincent Caso, Jeff Lewis, Amy Okuda, Sandeep Parikh, Robin Thorsen
Created By: Felicia Day
![]()
I prefer to review smaller webseries, but let’s face it, it’s impossible to ignore what a phenomenon The Guild has become. That’s why i decided it was about time I reviewed it.

I watched the first season of the guild on YouTube in 2008. Since then, they’ve produced two more seasons sponsored by Microsoft (as if you couldn’t guess by the irritating fact that all their computers have a Windows sticker over the actual logo. Window’s don’t make hardware, so what the heck’s going on there? Sorry, pet peeve. Back to the review.) which were released on Zune, Xbox and the Guild website.
This is my first criticism about the series. After power-watching through the first season on YouTube, I subscribed to their channel and waited for new episodes to drop into my subscription box. Of course, this never came. Later I learned about the move to Microsoft’s various markets and realized I had to seek out the second season, rather than let it come to me. Maybe that’s the reason I waited about a year before finally watching the second season.
Having to visit the website each week and sit through ads for Sprint, all just to watch just four or five minutes was also a bit of a dampener on my viewing enjoyment, which is why, for the past two seasons, I’ve waited until they’re all online, then watched through them all in one night. Although, on the other hand, that makes for a fun night, so it isn’t necessarily a bad thing. And let’s face it, they have to make money somehow.
As for the show itself: it started out with a very amateur-esque charm. It looked like it could have been made by a bunch of friends in their basement. Of course, the opposite was true. The production team was greater than any amateur webseries creator could put together and they certainly aimed high – and it didn’t take them long to go even higher. But what did you expect from Felicia day?
Her writing for the series is hard to fault. It flows well and the characters seem realistic, while also being entertaining. They’re charicatures of real life, something that every nerd out there can relate to. One of my favorite characters in terms of dialogue is Vork, the slow talking, montonous leader of the titular Guild, who’s serious tone makes every joke uttered pure gold.
The second season suddenly entered the realms of HD widescreen and it looked fantastic. The boosted production values brought a lot to the show without taking anything away – the great writing and great acting persisted and the hit become even more popular.
In the third – and most recent – season, Day introduced an interesting new storyline involving a new rival guild. The casting of this guild was as interesting as the storyline itself. We’ve been with our group of mismatched nerds for two years and now we get to see an alternate version of them with a dark twist. It’s just wonderful.
The cinematography seems to have been tweaked a tad in the third season, making it look even more perfect. I think they’re really hitting their stride and hopefully the fourth season will take them to even greater levels.
It has to be said that some of the funniest parts of each episode, and certainly my favorite, are the video blog sections at the beginning of each episode, where lead character Codex vents her feelings about recent events. They always end with a great line that keeps me laughing through the credits.
Which is good, because they have a really annoying opening theme.




